Last summer I had an interesting conversation with a couple of relatives. More distant relative, ultra successful, highly educated businessmen found out that I believe “evil supernatural beings” exist. After looking at me like I was a raving lunatic, he proceeded to pooh-pooh the idea by doing cartoonish impersonations of evil beings. It was quite funny, even though the laughs were at my expense. There was zero chance for a productive conversation, but later I thought about attitudes towards the supernatural.
Now I understand the reluctance to believe in certain supernatural elements, but I think we need to look a little closer at the issues to develop a consistent thought process. There are many people who consider belief in God to be a psychological coping mechanism or even a way for leaders to control people. And it is understandable when someone who holds this position denies the existence of angels and demons, Satan, even God because they deny the reality of the supernatural.
But there are many people who want to believe in a benevolent Deity but would not be inclined to believe in an actual evil being like Satan and be even less inclined to believe that he has agents that manifest themselves in our world.
But look whose foot is already in the door. It is the belief in something other than things proved by natural law. It is disturbing for us to think that there is an actual Force of Evil that may be at work, but much more comforting to believe in an all-loving God who may even send angels to help us out in need.
Look whose foot is already in the door; it is the belief in the supernatural, and it would be nice if we could have the good without all the evil, but it is inconsistent thinking. What source, other than our preference, would dictate to us, that we could have one without the other?
It seems like many people want to have their cake and eat it to. We don’t like the thought of evil at all even though most religions seem to believe that the benevolent Deity is more powerful, even has control of the devil-type. But people want to take it a step further and eliminate the forces of evil altogether.
I would be inclined to think that most people either really believe that there is no God or that people believe in both good and evil but simply stick their head in sand when it comes to supernatural. Either way, I think it is better if we are consistent in our thinking about the supernatural.